GOP Faces Midterm Warning as Traditional Republican Enthusiasm Lags

With control of Congress set to be determined in the coming weeks, Republican strategists are confronting a serious obstacle: Only about half of traditional Republicans say they are excited to vote.

Pollster Brent Buchanan, founder and CEO of Cygnal, presented the troubling finding during the debut episode of The Daily Signal’s “Midterm Report,” following the Republican National Committee’s first Midterm Convention in Dallas.

Buchanan described the Republican Party as a coalition of two major groups. Approximately 45% identify primarily as Trump Republicans, while a majority consider themselves traditional Republicans who are more closely connected to the party’s values and brand.

According to Cygnal’s polling, 77% of Trump Republicans are excited about the election. Among traditional Republicans, that number falls to 51%—a striking 26-point enthusiasm gap.

Buchanan argued that affordability must become a central part of the GOP’s message. Families continue to feel pressure from health insurance premiums, property taxes, auto and homeowners insurance, fuel prices, and other everyday expenses.

“Americans are actually focused on the money going out the door, not the money coming in the door,” he said while discussing President Donald Trump’s proposed $5,000 dividend.

Buchanan also warned Republicans against relying on “socialism” merely as a political label. Cygnal found that many Americans who consider socialism acceptable cannot clearly define it. He urged candidates to connect the ideology to specific proposals, including opening the border and defunding police departments.

Historian Victor Davis Hanson delivered a similarly urgent warning. Appearing to discuss his new book, “The Counterrevolution,” Hanson said Republicans face the historical reality that the president’s party usually loses ground during midterm elections.

However, he believes the GOP’s deeper problem is communication. Hanson cited border enforcement, deregulation, energy production, declining crime, foreign investment, and job creation as accomplishments Republicans have failed to explain effectively.

“It’s a pretty good message,” Hanson said, “but they’re not getting the message out.”

His forecast remains sobering: Republicans face difficult odds in the House, while control of the Senate may be a coin toss. The path forward, both guests agreed, requires clearly addressing affordability, contrasting policies, and bringing traditional Republican voters back into the fight.

Thank you for your support.

If you appreciate the work we do to spread the good news of Jesus Christ, please consider giving a gift to help us continue this work. Maranatha!